Exceptions Supervisor
Order Resolution & Investigations
Location:
Skokie, IL (Hybrid/Onsite) · Remote considered
Employment type:
Full-time · Salaried (Exempt)
About TicketVault
TicketVault builds the point-of-sale and inventory software that ticket sellers use to manage and sell tickets across the world's leading marketplaces. We're a fast-moving team in the live events industry, and we take pride in solving problems quickly and doing right by our clients.
About the Role
Not every order goes as planned, and that's where you come in. As our
Exceptions Supervisor, you'll lead a team of five, while handling your own share of escalated cases and investigations.
You'll be the calm, professional point of escalation when client and marketplace issues need extra attention. You'll find the root cause, fix it, and keep the work moving in a fast-paced, high-volume environment.
What You'll Do
Lead the team
Supervise, coach and develop the Exceptions team, including daily priorities, workload balancing, feedback and performance reviews
Own team workflows, queues and service levels, and build processes that keep exceptions handled consistently, quickly and accurately
Plan coverage, including weekend rotations during busy seasons, so the queue is never left unattended
Track and report team metrics (volume, resolution time, recovery and loss) and recommend improvements to leadership
Resolve substitutions, cancellations and order issues
Work your own caseload of escalated orders alongside the team
Resolve ticket substitutions, cancellations and order issues with clients and marketplaces, balancing customer outcomes with cost to the business
Serve as the escalation point for complex and sensitive concerns, with a calm, solutions-focused approach
Partner with Accounting on credits, chargebacks, refunds and reconciliations
Lead investigations
Lead and review investigations into disputed, failed or suspicious orders: gather evidence, document findings and recommend resolutions
Identify root causes and recurring patterns, and work with Product, Technology and Operations to prevent repeat issues
Analyze exception data to spot trends, quantify financial impact and support policy decisions
What You Bring
Required
4+ years in exceptions, escalations, order resolution, disputes or a similar operations role, including at least 1 year leading others (formally or as a team lead)
Strong problem-solving skills: you dig in, find the root cause and land on a fair, practical resolution
Composure and professionalism in high-stakes, time-sensitive conversations by phone, email and chat
Accuracy and good judgment in a fast-paced, high-volume environment
Working accounting knowledge: credits, refunds, chargebacks, reconciliations and reading transaction data
Strong Excel or Google Sheets skills (pivot tables, lookups), and comfort with reports and dashboards
A process-minded approach: you build, follow and improve workflows, queues and documentation
Familiarity with PBM
Clear written and verbal communication, and the judgment to know when to escalate
Nice to have
Experience in ticketing, live events, marketplaces or e-commerce operations
Experience with B2B SaaS, ticketing or point-of-sale systems, and tools like Power BI
Background in investigations, fraud or dispute resolution
Bachelor's degree in business, accounting, finance or a related field, or equivalent experience
Schedule & Location
Monday through Friday, plus required weekend rotations based on business needs
Chicagoland area is strongly preferred (our office is in Skokie, IL). Remote will be considered for the right candidate.
Compensation & Benefits
Base salary:
$75,000 – $95,000 per year, based on experience and skills
Benefits:
Medical, dental and vision insurance; 401(k); and paid time off (PTO)
Application Deadline
We anticipate the application window will close on December 13, 2026. If we extend it, we'll update this posting with the new date.
Equal Opportunity Employer
Ticket Vault LLC is an equal opportunity employer. We do not discriminate in hiring, employment or any terms and conditions of employment on the basis of race, color, religion, creed, sex, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, national origin, ancestry, citizenship status, age, marital status, physical or mental disability, military or veteran status, genetic information, arrest record, order of protection status, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state or local law. We provide reasonable accommodations for qualified individuals with disabilities and for religious beliefs. If you need an accommodation during the application or interview process, please contact People Operations.
Exceptions Supervisor in skokie at Unknown Company
This position is listed as full time and able to be worked remotely.